Stavrou, Marina, 2026, Thesis, The paradoxical image: Aporia and creative practice in Beckett and Borremans. A topographic inquiry PhD thesis, School of Arts & Humanities.
| Abstract or Description: | This thesis investigates aporia - the threshold where passage proves impossible yet abandonment equally unfeasible - as a generative methodology for creative practice and artistic research. Beginning with a bodily encounter at the 2011 Venice Biennale, where Diohandi's installation rendered the Greek financial crisis as suspended affect, the research asks: how does creative thought operate under aporetic conditions, and what forms emerge when artists work within constraint rather than beyond it? Through comparative analysis of Samuel Beckett's The Unnamable (1953) and Michaël Borremans' Automat I (2008), the thesis reveals shared aporetic structure beneath apparently disparate media. Both artists employ prosthetic devices (puppets, automata) enabling expression through indirection, work subtractively until only aporetic cores remain, and stage suspension demanding prolonged dwelling. This thesis names this peri-ergonic practice: not transcending impossibility but working around it (peri-, around; ergon, work). It also reads both artists through klisis (κλίσις), the inclination toward the unknown that is followed before the tools to meet it exist. Beckett sends language in every direction; Borremans lets the medium itself swerve, from sculpture to painting to video. The theoretical framework synthesises Jacques Derrida's concept of aporia as undecidability with Gilles Deleuze's difference-producing-repetition, where suspended meaning (Derrida) enables variation (Deleuze). to gestate. Beckett’s tympanum, the thin membrane vibrating between incompatible pressures, becomes the research’s methodological figure, and the synaptic-aporetic paradox, in which connection operates through disconnection, finds unexpected support in quantum physics and neuroscience. The Epicurean account of the eidola, thin films of atoms entering through the body’s pores rather than through the organised eye, grounds the central finding: pure aporia is impossible, since the threshold is always already traversed by images that organised perception cannot receive. Aporia is itself an eidolon, real in its effects but not in its nature. The methodological sequence follows: aporia suspends the organised channels of reception; theorein is the attentive beholding that inhabits the suspension from within; graphein is the mark the body makes before the mind has named what it received; and topographic inquiry is the collective drawing of the aporetic field as it is traversed. Practice-led investigation enacts this sequence. Reading Beckett while drawing with the non-dominant hand removes habitual fluency and activates distributed cognition across bodily systems. The post-theatre events Synaptic Galore, ET-Her and Post Scriptum; In the Wake of Dreams staged aporia as a spatial and sonic condition. Placed within sound- enveloped spaces and given coloured pencils and paper, with an invitation to move or draw if they wished, participants raised their hands, spread their fingers and reached before deciding to reach, the body rearranging itself toward what organised reception had closed off. Conversations with viewers of Automat I showed bodies adopting the automaton’s suspended posture before thought could name it. These responses are the trace of aporia, at once mark and enactment, the spectral presence of the threshold. The research proposes divergent coherence as the condition in which the artwork is created: its alter ego, the generative field of the work. Where Deleuze’s plane of consistency tends toward lateral connection and assemblage, divergent coherence holds elements in the same field without assembling them. Each participant’s response remains irreducibly singular, oriented toward the same suspended threshold, and together the responses compose a collective field. The thesis contributes to artistic research methodology a topographic inquiry that reopens each time the work is shared and calls for a technē or klisis that each person invents in their own way. It contributes to the understanding of creative cognition by showing how inattention, lapse and suspension facilitate imaginative emergence, and it names what this demands, in Golding’s phrase, ‘onto-epistemological courage’: the courage to remain in not-knowing long enough for knowledge to emerge differently. What began as crisis becomes the condition of transformation, a dwelling through which thought remakes itself at thresholds it cannot cross yet cannot abandon. The thesis further proposes a new reading of both Beckett and Borremans as practitioners of klisis (κλίσις): the pull toward the unknown, followed before the tools to meet it are known. Both artists show the passion of aporia as lived condition, the vertigo being drawn toward something frightening and unidentifiable. Beckett sends language everywhere (theorein), touching all sides of this inclination however terrifying and syntactically impossible; Borremans changes material, sculpture becoming painting, becoming video, and almost a theatrical act, the medium itself swerving as the klisis demands. Aporia, this research argues, is itself an eidolon, real in its effects but not in its nature, and both artists look it directly in the eye and continue. This continuation calls for what Golding names 'onto- epistemological courage': the courage to remain in not-knowing long enough for knowledge to emerge differently. |
|---|---|
| Qualification Name: | PhD |
| School or Centre: | School of Arts & Humanities |
| Additional Information: | Some elements of this thesis have been redacted for reasons of copyright |
| Uncontrolled Keywords: | aporia, Samuel Beckett, Michaël Borremans, drawing, notation |
| Date Deposited: | 16 Nov 2026 12:02 |
| Last Modified: | 16 Nov 2026 12:02 |
| URI: | https://researchonline.rca.ac.uk/id/eprint/6949 |
![]() |
Edit Item (login required) |
Lists
Lists